Summary
A new open access study in Forest Ecology and Management documents striking patterns of old growth mortality in eastern Oregon’s unlogged forests. Researchers found that:
-
One in four trees 300 years and older died within a single decade (2012 to 2023).
-
Older trees are particularly vulnerable, with growth decline (measured as basal area increment) a strong predictor of mortality.
-
Younger trees are not replacing these losses, raising concerns about long term forest resilience.
Importantly, the study was conducted in unlogged, roadless areas, including the Strawberry Mountain Wilderness and several Research Natural Areas. These sites are often viewed as ecological baselines, yet even here, drought, insect outbreaks, and competition are driving significant losses of the oldest trees.
Abstract
We investigated recent forest mortality dynamics by revisiting a network of 1617 trees in unlogged roadless areas in the Blue Mountains of eastern Oregon for which we have precise age and growth data. There was extensive mortality of the oldest trees in stands—a quarter of trees ≥300 years of age died over a ten-year period. Trees with below average increment and older trees were more likely to die in stands that have not experienced wildfire in the last 130 years. Smaller trees were more likely to die in stands that experienced wildfire during the ten-year observation period. Douglas-fir and western juniper experienced a lower rate of mortality than ponderosa , western larch, or grand fir in sites that have not experienced wildfire. There was little evidence for a difference in mortality between species in sites that experienced wildfire. We describe a novel simulation model which demonstrated that succession of young trees is unlikely to replace recent losses of old trees. The confluence of a rare insect defoliator outbreak, drought, and past management decisions that increased competitive stress and fuel connectivity is the most likely explanation for the elevated mortality we observed. The where we collected data are not achieving old tree conservation objectives. Active management to reduce forest competition is the most realistic pathway for old tree conservation in dry forests.
Citation
James D. Johnston, Paige N. Stephens, Micah R. Schmidt, Sean M.A. Jeronimo, Amanda E. Brackett, Amarina E. Wuenschel, Danielle E.M. Ulrich, Riley H. Paine, Lou F. Duloisy, Skye M. Greenler, Andrew J. Larson, Derek J. Churchill. Significant mortality of old trees across a dry forest landscape, Oregon, USA, Forest Ecology and Management 593 (2025). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foreco.2025.122907.